bananas ripening for the banana cake

THE  Banana Cake

Something strange has been happening in my house lately. I’ve taken to buying  hands of  deliciously ripe bananas and guarding them like a hawk. If one of my kids asks if they can eat a banana, they get a  resounding “No, they’re not for eating… yet”  The large bowl of yellow bananas sits tauntingly on the kitchen bench, teasing and tempting all that pass it by, but they know these bananas aren’t for eating… yet.  What could be so special as to halt the consumption of perfectly ripe bananas. Well,  BANANA CAKE of course.

First I bought you “Banana and coconut bread”,  then I introduced its brother “Banana and Chocolate bread” followed by their good looking sister “guilt free banana bread” Now I would like to introduce  you to the Granddaddy of all banana cakes and bread. Plain and simply put,  THE Banana Cake. This banana cake has caused me to reevaluate  our fresh fruit eating options, opting now  for snacks of pineapple, passionfruit and kiwifruit in  place of what would normally be a bite of creamy banana.

banana cake

This banana cake is responsible for a long running feud between myself and my good friend Tina back home in New Zealand who reckons that her version of banana cake is superior to mine. A verbal game of badminton has been playing out between us via facebook   for some time now which has promoted me to up my game. I’ve taken banana cake making to a scientific level. The why, the which and of course the important how.

The first banana cake I ever made was from  the Edmond’s Cookbook, an iconic  and popular cookbook  found in almost every kitchen in New Zealand.  But I’m sorry Edmond’s Sure to Rise, this cake is far superior to your scantily written recipe. I’ve sought  the consultation of some of the worlds thought leaders on molecular gastronomy, Herve This and Harold McGee on the matter attaining to chemical reactions within baked goods in order to better understand the transformations that are taking place when the banana cake is being prepared and  cooking ~ also known as getting my food geek-on.

Brown sugar weighed for the banana cake

I came to  realize a very important point whilst researching the maillard reaction and other wonderful scientific observations and how it releates to banana cake baking  and that was the all important banana element itself. How important is it to leave your banana’s to go  brown naturally as opposed to assisting the process by squishing and  stuffing bananas into the fridge or freezer to speed up the browning process?

cake mixer with banana cake batter on low speed

Firstly refrigeration under normal circumstances eg 2-4C actually slows down the browning process of the banana flesh. The banana skin will most certainly go brown but the ripening process of the banana will slow significantly. Freezing the banana  will certainly turn it mushy, but will not result in the banana ripening with the major noticeable difference in the banana being the loss in quality in  flesh of the banana.

The reason you want your banana to ripen, as opposed to going brown is that as the banana ripens, starch within the banana naturally breaks down into the sugars glucose, fructose and sucrose ~ making them sweeter! So leave your bananas well enough alone as they need the time left on the bench to convert their starch into the much more appealing sugar and assist you to Banana cake baking glory!

Banana cake batter

How long should you leave your bananas? Dependant on how ripe you buy them, a good week or so in a warm kitchen should about do the trick. If your kitchen is cooler, leave them longer.

All has been done in the attempt to perfect the humble banana cake recipe as there is a grand canyon of difference between a good banana cake and a great moist banana cake.  You be the judge, follow this easy recipe for yourself taking into account the notes and tips that will lead you to ambrosia like success. What might seem trivial to you, may actually be the difference between a parade in your honor or a half nibbled slice left on the plate.


THE Banana Cake


Makes 1 20-22 cm round cake

190g unsalted butter ~  cut into cubes and softened at room temperature

200g dark brown sugar

60g caster sugar

3 large eggs

4 very ripe mashed banana’s

3 Tbsp milk ~ brought to the boil

1 1/2 tsp baking soda

330g self raising flour

1/2 tsp salt

Slice of beautiful Banana cake


Preheat the oven to Fan bake on 165 C/ 320 F. Ready the shelf in the middle of the oven.

Into a large bowl, or cake mixer bowl place the softened butter, dark brown sugar and caster sugar and cream well with a wooden spoon or cake mixer paddle until light and fluffy and the sugar begins to dissolve. This should take about  3 minutes of steady mixing.

Add the eggs one at a time, mixing well between each addition. At this stage of the cake making process, mixing well is essential to fully incorporate the ingredients and it also helps to incorporate air into the mix which will assist the cake in rising upon baking.

Peel and mash the bananas well with a fork and mix them through the batter mixture. Bring to the boil the milk and stir into it the baking powder. You will notice the mixture becomes frothy, which is the bicarb soda reacting with the hot milk. This will help to get good rise out of the cake as it cooks. Add this mixture to the butter, sugar and eggs.

Sift the flour and add to the mixing bowl along with the salt. Fold gently and evenly until combined, making sure not to over mix at this stage as over mixing could result in a tough rubbery cake.

Spray a 20-22cm non stick springform cake-tin with nonstick cooking spray and pour the batter into the tin. Tap gently to even out the mixture and place on a shelf in the middle of a pre heat oven.

Bake for 50-60 minutes or until a skewer inserted into the middle of the cake comes out clean.

Cool on a wire rack and serve The banana cake in big slices with butter or whipped cream.

If you like this Banana cake post, make sure to share it with your friends!

Visit Bridget Davis’s profile on Pinterest.




  1. Chloewilson7 said…

    cool im going to try this out 

  2. It’s amazing designed for me to have a website,
    which is beneficial for my know-how. thanks admin

  3. 香水 激安 said…

    Thank you for the good writeup. It in fact was
    a amusement account it. Look advanced to far added agreeable from you!
    By the way, how could we communicate?

    my web-site; 香水 激安

Leave a Comment

With 20+ years working in commercial kitchens, I’m here to share with you some of the best secrets of the trade to help you cook better, faster and to eat well. You will surprise a lot of family & friends when you give some of my recipes a try.